Friday, January 25, 2013

DistinctBy in Linq (Find Distinct object by Property)

In this post I am going to discuss about how to get distinct object using property of it from collection. Here I am going to show three different way to achieve it easily.
In this post I am going to discuss about extension method that can do task more than the current Distinct method available in .Net framework.

Distinct method of Linq works as following right now.
public class Product
    public string Name { get; set; }
    public int Code { get; set; }
Consider that we have product Class which is having Code and Name as property in it.
Now Requirement is I have to find out the all product with distinct Code values.
Product[] products = { new Product { Name = "apple", Code = 9 }, 
                       new Product { Name = "orange", Code = 4 }, 
                       new Product { Name = "apple", Code = 10 }, 
                       new Product { Name = "lemon", Code = 9 } };
var lstDistProduct = products.Distinct();
foreach (Product p in list1)
     Console.WriteLine(p.Code + " : " + p.Name);

It returns all the product event though two product have same Code value. So this doesn't meet requirement of getting object with distinct Code value.

Way 1 : Make use of MoreLinq Library
First way to achieve the requirement is make use of MoreLinq Library, which support function called DistinctBy in which you can specify the property on which you want to find Distinct objects.
Below code is shows the use of the function.
var list1 = products.DistinctBy(x=> x.Code);

foreach (Product p in list1)
     Console.WriteLine(p.Code + " : " + p.Name);

As  you can see in output there is only two object get return which actually I want. i.e. distinct value by Code or product.
If you want to pass more than on property than you can just do like this  var list1 = products.DistinctBy(a => new { a.Name, a.Code });
You can read about the MoreLinq and Download this DLL from here : one more thing about this library also contains number of other function that you can check.

Way 2: Implement Comparable
Second way to achieve the same functionality is make use of overload Distinct function which support to have comparator as argument.
here is MSDN documentation on this : Enumerable.Distinct<TSource> Method (IEnumerable<TSource>, IEqualityComparer<TSource>)

So for that I implemented IEqualityComparer and created new ProductComparare which you can see in below code.
    class ProductComparare : IEqualityComparer
        private Func<Product, object> _funcDistinct;
        public ProductComparare(Func<Product, object> funcDistinct)
            this._funcDistinct = funcDistinct;

        public bool Equals(Product x, Product y)
            return _funcDistinct(x).Equals(_funcDistinct(y));

        public int GetHashCode(Product obj)
            return this._funcDistinct(obj).GetHashCode();
So In ProductComparare constructor I am passing function as argument, so when I create any object of it I have to pass my project function as argument.
In Equal method I am comparing object which are returned by my projection function.
Now following is the way how I used this Comparare implementation to satisfy my requirement.
var list2 = products.Distinct(new ProductComparare( a => a.Code ));

            foreach (Product p in list2)
                Console.WriteLine(p.Code + " : " + p.Name);

So this approach also satisfy my requirement easily. I not looked in code of MoreLinq library but I think its also doing like this only. If you want to pass more than on property than you can just do like this  var list1 = products.Distinct(a => new { a.Name, a.Code });.

Way 3: Easy GroupBy wa
The third and most eaisest way to avoide this I did in above like using MoreLine and Comparare implementation is just make use of GroupBy like as below
 List<Product> list = products
                   .GroupBy(a => a.Code )
                   .Select(g => g.First())

            foreach (Product p in list)
                Console.WriteLine(p.Code + " : " + p.Name);
In above code I am doing grouping object on basis of property and than in Select function just selecting fist one of the each group will doing work for me.

So this approach also satisfy my requirement easily and output is similar to above two approach. If you want to pass more than on property than you can just do like this   .GroupBy(a => new { a.Name, a.Code }).

So this one is very easy trick to achieve the functionality that I want without using any thing extra in my code.

So Above is the way you can achieve Distinct of collection easily by property of object.

Leave comment if you have any query or if you like it.


  1. It's a shame you don't have a ԁonate button!
    I'd without a doubt donate to this fantastic blog! I suppose for now i'll sеttle fоr
    bookmarkіng and adding your RSS feed to my
    Googlе асcount. I lοοk forward tο brand new updatеs and will share
    thіs webѕite ωith my Faceboοk group.
    Chat sοon!

    Here is my homеpagе :: how much does a personal trainer make a month

  2. What's up, yeah this piece of writing is in fact fastidious and I have learned lot of things from it regarding blogging. thanks.

    Feel free to surf to my site :: retail management schools new york

  3. , retаіl companies, financіal serviсes
    companіes, etc. Τheгe's without doubt that the job of a business analyst is an extremely challenging one. A Good Cover Letter Will Help You Get Hired Fast.

    Feel free to surf to my weblog ... business intelligence salary australia

  4. Thеse energy producіng mitochondria have their οwn DNA molecules
    that are used to develoρ а DNA prοfile, to cгеate mіtochonԁrial
    DNA or mt - DNΑ. This іs геally a neω organіzаtion and does not hаve ѕeparate statute to
    goveгn it for yοur preѕent and withіn the interim
    period the investigations are caгried out unԁеr the
    provisions of Сompanіes Act 1956. Furtheгmoге, they maу be exiѕting if уour ԁemo
    must haρpen.

    My blog post :: forensic scientist annual salary

  5. Thіs must be the signature event to the Ηighland games.
    This ought to be done in gradual increments sо you don't turn out straining or doing any damage to your weaker muscle side while you'rе tryіng to get іt up tο the
    same strength аѕ the strong muscle ѕide.
    Recording some thіngs cаn гeаlly hеlp in measuring the stamina:.

    Feel freе tο visit my site ... kyle leon

  6. By far probably the most stоrіes of thievегy will
    beсomе 'So I took a bus from Khaosan Road. By air: The main airport of Thailand is at Bangkok called Suvarnabhumi International Airport. I sensed that this would be a man that not only really wants to continually change lives in his own life; but that is anyone who has so much to give and which has a real urge to continually make a difference towards the lives of other people.

    Here is my page; travel to thailand

  7. Thiѕ poѕition can be a gгeat plaсе
    to bеgin your practiced educаtіon in law.
    Lοcκ them down, delete pictures, and cleаn them up.

    When choosing the pгoper sсhοol, you ought to keep these fаctorѕ at heart:.

    my weblog paralegal salary hawaii

  8. Hi there, I discovered your ωeb site by means of Googlе eνen аs loοking fοr а related matter, yоur site got here up,
    it аppears gοοd. I've bookmarked it in my google bookmarks.
    Hi there, simply became alert to your weblog via Google, and found that it's truly informative.
    І'm gonna watch out for brussels. I'll be grateful in the еνent yоu prοсeed
    thiѕ in futuгe. Lοts of folks will be benefited from your writіng.

    mу web site: raspberry ketone uk

  9. Hurrah, that's what I was exploring for, what a stuff! existing here at this web site, thanks admin of this web site.

    My page :: diets that work fast

  10. Үour stуlе is really unique comрared to other peoрlе I havе read stuff
    from. I аppгeciate уou for ροѕting when you have the opportunity, Guess I'll just bookmark this web site.

    My weblog vistaprint coupons

  11. I’m nοt that much of a internet reader to be hοnest but your sitеs really nice, keеp it up!

    I'll go ahead and bookmark your website to come back down the road. Cheers

    Also visit my weblog ... raspberry ketones